Judge Dismisses Developers Lawsuit to Evict Ohr Natan Shul and its 1000 Bukharian Jewish Members


ohr-natan-shul-queensQueens, NY – A Queens Civil Judge has dismissed a lawsuit by developers to evict a major shul of Bukharian Jews in the Queens Blvd/Rego Park area. The landlords, developers who are planning to demolish the beautiful synagogue when its lease ends in 2017 in favor of a large development, were seeking to evict the synagogue immediately through trumped up legal charges of non-payment of rent, a charge Ohr Natan denied, citing proof of its attempts to pay the rent. Judge Terrence C. O’Connor agreed with Ohr Natan and dismissed the lawsuit.

“We are ecstatic that the Judge saw through this frivolous lawsuit and saved the shul for now, although the developers are still bent on putting 1000 Jews who lived through Communism out on the street,” said Rabbi Nahum Kaziev, the spiritual leaders of Ohr Natan. He called on the developers to do the right thing and “come to a Bais Din,” something they have refused to do and which resulted in a Tzav Ikul (injunction) by the Bais Din of the Vaad Harabbonim of Queens.

More than 50 residents of Rego Park jammed into a 4th floor courtroom of the Queens Civil Court last Friday as the synagogue and community center Ohr Natan fought back attempts from the developers to evict the shul. They were there in support of their beloved rabbi, Nahum Kaziev and the Ohr Natan synagogue and community center he heads.

In addition to the broad community support, two elected officials who represent the Rego Park area signed a joint letter to Rabbi Kaziev noting that “it is very important that you are able to continue to work and serve the people of Queens.” Congresswoman Grace Meng and Councilwoman Karen Koslowitz praised the work of the organization, noting: “The Bukharian community in Queens is thriving and your center is an integral part of this development.” In another major letter of support and direct appeal to the developers, Cynthia Zalisky, the Executive Director of the Queens Jewish Community Council, which represents 146 organizations, noted: “The Educational Center for New Americans (Ohr Natan) is an essential organization that needs to continue its important work within the immigrant community. We strongly urge you to allow this Center to serve the constituents for the remainder of the lease. Anything else would cause irrefutable hardship on the Bukharians living in the area that need and depend on its services so much.”

Founded in 1986, Ohr Natan invested more than $2.1 to renovate the old Trylon Theater on Queens Blvd as well as $1.2 million in rent as one of the major shuls and community centers for the area’s large Bukharian Jewish population. The Trylon LLC developers that acquired the building had informed Ohr Natan of their intention to build a housing development on the site leaving the shul and its 1000 members “on the street.” According to Rabbi Nachum Kaziev, spiritual leader and head of Ohr Natan, “once the developers became aware of our intent to fight the planned 2017 eviction when our lease officially ends, they began a series of legal maneuvers that would move up the date of expulsion to as early as weeks from now.” He said that the Bukharian Jews were already denied any access to their ancient heritage as a result of living under Communism for 70 years, are being actively recruited by missionaries and now face the ultimate rejection as the shul and center they have adopted sends them packing.”

In addition to its fully functioning shul with tefillois and shiurim, Ohr Natan offers a full program of after school programs, adult education (including ESL), food distribution and many events. Since 1991, it publishes Druzhba, a monthly magazine with a readership of 80,000 people throughout the five boroughs, the largest publications read by immigrants of the former Soviet Union.

Rabbi Kaziev issued an urgent plea to save the shul and the “neshomos of 1000 Jews who may potentially be lost to our people forever as the danger of assimilation threatens to take its toll on this group of Jews.”

{Matzav.com Newscenter}


  1. Could someone explain on what basis they plan tofight when their lease ends? Why should the landlord not have the right to knock down his building?

  2. Good to read that there are still some good, fair and truthful judges around. Afraid they are getting fewer and fewer. So glad to read the outcome for these Bukharian Jews. May they go from strength to strength and thrive.

  3. As somebody that came here without much knowledge about Judaism, I got so much from this shul.
    I came for the kids program, lectures, shiurim…
    And now Baruch Hashem I’m married and torah observing jew.
    There are hundreds of yidden like me thanks to ohr natan.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here