FLACK: New York Times’ David Brooks Catches Flak for Shabbos Column


By Ira Stoll

New York Times columnist David Brooks is getting some pushback after a column about the Sabbath in which he writes, “On this day the Orthodox do less and in slowness can glimpse the seeds of eternity.”

It’s not entirely clear whether the “do less” formulation is that of Brooks or that of Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel, on whom Brooks relies and quotes for several paragraphs of the column. The words don’t appear in quotes in the Times column, but the previous sentence is paraphrased and attributed to Heschel.

Regardless of their origin, they rubbed at least some Jewish readers the wrong way. “Do less?!?!? @nytdavidbrooks, you are invited to shadow my average Shabbos,” tweeted Avital Chizhik Goldschmidt, an editor at The Forward. For Orthodox Jews who host large meals for many guests on Friday nights and at Saturday lunch, the supposed day of rest may be busier than some weekdays, even if the cooking has been done in advance. While there are some things, such as work, that observant Jews do less of on the Sabbath, there are other things that observant Jews do more of on the Sabbath, such as, for example, read from the Torah.

One Conservative rabbi, Jonah Geffen, also objected, pointing out that it’s not exclusively Orthodox Jews who slow down or cease work on Shabbos.

The Brooks column said in part:

The great philosopher of time is Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel. In his great book “The Sabbath,” he points out that the first sacred thing in the Bible is not a thing, it is a time period, the seventh day. Judaism, he argues, is primarily a religion of time, not space.

“The seventh day,” he writes, “is a palace in time which we build. It is made of soul, of joy and reticence. In its atmosphere, a discipline is a reminder of adjacency to eternity. Indeed, the splendor of the day is expressed in terms of abstentions.”

The Sabbath, he continues, is not a rest from the other six days. It is the peak experience the other six days point toward. On this day the Orthodox do less and in slowness can glimpse the seeds of eternity.

Sabbath, Heschel concludes, “is endowed with a felicity which enraptures the soul, which glides into our thoughts with a healing sympathy. It is a day on which hours do not oust one another. It is a day that can soothe all sadness away. No one, even the unlearned, crude man, can remain insensitive to its beauty.”

As one person put it on Twitter, sometimes less is more.

The Algemeiner Journal



  1. In truth, however, in the world of kedushah time, place, and Man share, perhaps equally.

    There are zemanei kodesh; Chanukah and Purim, Rosh Chodesh, Cholo shel Mo’ed, Yom Tov Yom Kippur, and Shabbos. There are mekomos ha’kedoshim; Eretz Yisroel, Yerushalayim, Har HaBayis, Ezras Noshim, Ezras Yisroel, the Kodesh, and finally, the Kodesh HaKadoshim. And there are anshei kodesh; Yisroelim, Levi’im, Kohanim, Kohanim Gedolim. On Yom Kippur, the Kohein Gadol enters the Beis Kodesh HaKadoshim. And all three dimensions come together.

    The Nesivos Shalom points out in Tazria that the machalah of tzora’as is found in less physical form today in those individuals who do not sense kedushah; in Shabbos, in Yomim Tovim, in davenning, in learning. He explains the refuah is to kling to talmidei chachomim mush as the tzaruah brought himself to the Kohein.

Leave a Reply to RAM Cancel reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here